Jerry Falwell Sr. Was Right, or Empirical Evidence Is Not Everything
I recently happened across a social-media discussion that was primarily about absolute truth vs. relativism but had meandered into sexuality politics. One person, a self-professed Christian, argued with another Christian who was being critical of the homosexual agenda. The more liberal commenter said that he did not understand Christian criticism of homosexuality since homosexuality “does not hurt anyone.”
A few years ago, I encountered the same comment in one of my college classrooms. Every student in the room was a great student who would be considered conservative by modern cultural standards, and every student in the room was from an evangelical home. As the students and I discussed a number of cultural issues around which secular and biblical thinking collide, I was happy to find that all of the students embraced a biblical perspective about those collision points…until I broached the subject of homosexuality. When the conversation moved to the homosexual agenda, every student, to a person, affirmed the thinking of one student who did not understand why many Christians were so bent out of shape about homosexuality, since “it doesn’t hurt anyone.”
The wrongness of that particular assertion is well documented. For example, even the United States government knows that HIV and AIDS are much more prevalent in the male homosexual community than in other populations,1 and the cost of treatment on the U.S. budget and therefore on the American taxpayer is astronomical. Moreover, it is a fact that children raised by gay parents (either male or female) opposed to male and female parents in a traditional family encounter far more social and emotional problems.2 However, my concern in this essay is not to elaborate on the social and cultural damage that the LGBTQ agenda causes but to confront the theological ignorance and biblical illiteracy that the “doesn’t-hurt-anyone” assertion betrays.
Two days after September 11, 2001, the late Dr. Jerry Falwell Sr. suggested that the tragic events of 9-11 were God’s way of punishing the United States for endorsing all manner of sin such as abortion and homosexuality. He later issued an apology for singling out “abortionists,” “feminists,” “gays and lesbians,” “the ACLU,” and “People for the American Way,”3 but he was widely criticized by people from across the ideological and religious spectrums. Even Christian leaders criticized the comments, noting that there was a presumptuousness in Falwell’s comments that deserved criticism. That is, he seemed to be saying that he knew the mind of God, that he understood God’s exact reasons for allowing the tragedies of that horrific morning.
Falwell’s presumptuousness, however, was not what got him in trouble with a lot of the public. Many people were offended simply because they disagreed with the idea of abortion and homosexuality being morally wrong. Others were offended because the idea of a good God who would discipline a nation or a people for disobedience did not comport with their worldview and their understanding of God. After all, many Americans’ view of God is simply that “God is love.”
While Falwell might have been presumptuous and wrong to single out certain people groups as he did, the theology that provided the framework for his comment was not wrong. The fact of the matter is that there is a spiritual dimension to our sin that does not necessarily correlate to empirical evidence that may or may not be demonstrated by the observable consequences of it. Unfortunately, we find ourselves in a culture that says if something does not lead to immediate and observable negative consequences, then that something must be morally acceptable. If one points out the actions-have-spiritual-consequences doctrine today, even a lot of churched people will be encountering a new teaching.
Perhaps much of our church culture has abandoned the actions-have-spiritual-consequences doctrine for the same reason it has abandoned other doctrines and other elements of truth over the years. That is, maybe people have overreacted to an abuse of the doctrine. To be sure, some Christians have suggested that every bad thing that happens to a person is rooted in that person’s disobedience. Distaste for the abused extreme of this doctrine is understandable: Uncle Joe did not have cancer and Grandma Betty did not have Parkinson’s disease because they were “bad people” or because they did something that angered God. Such messages are hurtful and just plain wrong. Every bad thing that happens is not a direct result of someone’s sin (though it is a result of a fallen world caused by sin in general [see Genesis 3]).
As we often do when we react to a doctrinal abuse, however, I fear that we have thrown the baby out with the bathwater. Disobedience to God has negative effects in our lives and relationships that might not be as immediately observable as the sin of stealing someone’s money or drinking too much alcohol and then getting behind the wheel of a car. A general principle in Scripture is that God responds favorably to obedience and unfavorably to disobedience—and he may respond in ways that do or do not make sense to us.
The books of 1 and 2 Kings and 1 and 2 Chronicles underscore this point as powerfully as any other books in the Bible, and the reader of these Old Testament books does not need a PhD in biblical studies to see it. One of the most important thematic messages of these four books is that the sin and obedience of nations—and their leaders—have spiritual consequences.
The focus on Josiah in 2 Kings and 2 Chronicles is especially instructive. Josiah was one of the last kings of Judah—and Judah, just like Israel, had strayed from God’s laws and had a series of bad kings who fostered a culture of idol worship. In fact, idol worship had become so rampant, and the leaders and citizenry had strayed so far from God’s laws, that the people no longer even realized that a book of God’s laws existed. According to 2 Kings 22:8 and 2 Chronicles 34:14, the Book of the Law (Scripture) was found during Josiah’s reign, and when Josiah heard the Book of the Law read aloud, he tore his robes because he realized how much God’s anger burned against the nation due to the disobedience of previous generations (2 Kings 22:11–13; 2 Chronicles 34:19–21). Josiah responded appropriately and called together “all the elders of Judah and Jerusalem” and renewed the people’s covenant with God (2 Kings 23:1–3; 2 Chronicles 34:29–31).
Upon renewing the covenant, Josiah went to work not only tearing down the idols but also destroying them completely. After all, at the end of the Book of the Covenant, which is the section of civil and ceremonial commandments that follows the Ten Commandments in Exodus, we read that God had commanded his people to not merely disavow idols but to “demolish them and break their sacred stones to pieces” (Exod. 23:24). Throughout 2 Kings 23, we read how Josiah took this commandment seriously. Josiah’s obedience to a centuries-old command of God—one that had been ignored by almost all former kings—was thorough.
Moreover, Josiah’s obedience led to God’s blessing. Even though God had already determined to bring disaster upon Judah because of generations of idol worship, God promised Josiah that he would stay his hand while Josiah was alive and that he would not allow the king to see the demise of his nation (2 Kings 22:20). In this detail, we see both the positive and the negative aspects of the actions-have-spiritual-consequences doctrines at work. The disobedience of previous kings incited God’s judgment, and the obedience of Josiah led to God’s blessing.
Coincidentally, we should not miss the relationship between a leader’s relationship with God and the effects of that relationship on those he or she leads. Under Josiah’s leadership, “All the people pledged themselves to the covenant” (2 Kings 23:3). Moreover, “As long as he [Josiah] lived, they [the people of Judah] did not fail to follow the Lord, the God of their fathers” (2 Chronicles 35:33). In other words, as the leadership went, so went the people. Obedient, committed leadership resulted in obedient, committed people. And as we’ve already seen, God tends to respond favorably to obedience and unfavorably to disobedience. This reality is only one of many reasons that I cringe when I hear people say that certain types of sins “don’t hurt anyone.” Obedience matters, leadership matters, and obedience in leadership matters.
The Lord’s favor that was on Josiah trickled down to the people—just as the sin of wayward kings also trickled down to the people. We may not see immediate, empirical evidence of sin’s negative consequences, but there is an unseen spiritual dynamic between us and God that is no less real—and the details of that dynamic will eventually play out before us.
Despite our culture’s uncomfortableness with the idea that a loving God might discipline a people or a nation for its disobedience, and despite our culture’s tendency to call anything morally acceptable if it does not have immediate and observable negative consequences, we need to reclaim the actions-have-spiritual-consequences doctrine, lest we end up with a church culture that condones every possible behavior that does not produce immediate and observable negative consequences.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Fast Facts: HIV and Gay and Bisexual Men,” October 7, 2024, https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/data-research/facts-stats/gay-bisexual-men.html.
↩︎ - Peter Sprigg, “Homosexual Parent Study: Summary of Findings,” Family Research Council, August 2012, http://downloads.frc.org/EF/EF12H47.pdf.
↩︎ - Jerry Falwell Sr., quoted in Laurie Goodstein, “Falwell: Blame Abortionists, Feminists, and Gays,” The Guardian, September 19, 2001, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/sep/19/september11.usa9.
↩︎

