United States Supreme Court building with columns and steps

From a National Aversion to Higher Taxes to Communist Enthusiasm in 34 Years: The Road to Zohran Mamdani’s Mayoral Victory

Only 38 short years ago, in 1988, the people of the United States decisively elected 41st President George Herbert Walker Bush based in part on a principled campaign promise: “Read my lips: no new taxes.” The nation subsequently voted him out of office four years later in large part because he compromised with Congress and raised taxes, breaking that promise. Only eleven U.S. presidents have ever failed to win a second-term campaign, so the historical magnitude of Bush’s election loss cannot be understated: only 34 years ago, Americans rejected tax increases, sending a message that they desired to keep as much of their personal income as they possibly could.

Fast forward to 2025: the people of the largest and most important city in the country, New York City, elected self-professed socialist Zohran Mamdani as their mayor. Though Mamdani denies supporting full-fledged communism, his rhetoric suggests otherwise. He has spoken of a belief in “seizing the means of production”1 and the “warmth of collectivism,”2 thus expressing ideas and phraseology that trace back directly to Karl Marx’s The Communist Manifesto and the fundamental political beliefs shared by a number of communist leaders, including Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin in the twentieth century.

Lest anyone reading to this point believe that such political preferences are limited to the generally progressive nature of New Yorkers, a March 2026 Fox News poll should prove instructive. This poll indicated that “a record 38% [of Americans] think it would be a good thing for the United States to move away from capitalism and in the direction of socialism—up from 32% in 2022.” The Fox News article summarizing this data also noted that only 18% percent of Americans embraced socialism in 2010.3

So how did our nation get to this point? How did our country go from voting out a sitting president in 1992 for breaking his “no new taxes” promise, to embracing socialism at a rate of 38% and electing a self-professed socialist (who is arguably a full-fledged communist) to be the mayor of its largest and most important city? In 1992, the majority of voters indicated that they wanted to keep more of their money, but in 2026, increasing numbers of voters believe it would be a good idea to hand more of their earnings over to the government. How did such a huge philosophical shift in the American psyche occur in just 34 years?

For sure, the answer has to do with decades of indoctrination and social engineering led by progressives in the media and in all levels of education. I believe, however, that one particular aspect of the social-engineering agenda has been especially important in undermining the traditional American value of economic liberty and replacing it with the very un-American ideals of collectivism and income redistribution.

A lesson from Vladimir Lenin’s Soviet Russia is instructive for understanding how we in the United States have arrived at the current moment.

I recently watched filmmaker Bill Whittle’s captivating eight-part documentary about the twentieth-century Russian Revolution, titled What We Saw: An Empire of Terror. In the fourth episode of the series, Whittle makes an important observation about a particular dynamic of the European upheaval of the early 1920s. As a man committed to Marxist principles, Lenin believed that the revolution that began in Russia would surely spread to France and beyond. After all, Marx believed that a global revolution of the working class against the property-owning class was inevitable, and since Lenin was a true believer in Marxist ideology, he wanted to see that global revolution. Moreover, he thought that the Russian Revolution was sure to be the event that would ignite the communist fire across the West and the rest of the globe. Consequently, Lenin was shocked when the French did not have the same appetite for the class-based revolution that had impacted Russia so drastically.

So what happened? Why did what was supposed to be inevitable in France fail to come to fruition? The answer requires just a bit of a history lesson.

Unbeknownst to both the Russian people and the French, Lenin was actually a tool for the German leaders. Before his rise to power, Lenin had self-exiled to Germany to escape imprisonment by the Russian Tsar, and it was Germany that funded his return to Russia when the time was right. Germany saw an opportunity in Lenin’s radicalism to help its own cause. Germany wanted Lenin to lead a revolution in Russia as a way to deal with the problem of the Eastern front. That is, Germany gambled that Lenin could lead a revolution so massive in Russia that the revolution itself would become way more important than Russian resistance to Germany—and Russia would thus stop fighting the Germans. After Lenin had told the Russian people for three years that he would pull Russia out of World War I, the Germans were ready to see that promise fulfilled—and Lenin had little choice but to enter peace negotiations with Germany.

Whittle’s narration at this point in the documentary is extremely important for understanding the growing acceptance of socialist principles in the United States:

The French, whose alliance with Russia had long predated the Great War and whose country had been shelled and churned and grounded to hamburger, were practically apoplectic [because of Lenin’s willingness to seek peace with Germany]. “What!” exclaimed Gustae Hervé, a French political socialist whom the Bolsheviks presumably would expect to be on the team. “Talk with Lenin…after he has broken treaties with us? After abandoning us in the middle of the war? Never!”

See, this is the blind spot that […] Lenin […] could [n]ever see past. The idea that French, or British, or German socialists would identify with their own nations rather than their international socialist brothers perpetually amazed [Lenin and his comrades].4 [my emphasis]

In other words, French patriotism was stronger than the desire to engage in a risky pursuit of a communist utopia anchored in rebellion and revolution. The French national identity was an obstacle to Lenin’s global-revolution hopes as a true believer in Marxism.

Now let’s return to twenty-first century America.

Have you ever wondered why so many progressives in the United States are obsessed with painting our nation in the worst light possible? It is because they learned from Lenin’s experience: they understand that the one reality that undermined Lenin’s hopes for global communism was national pride. Consequently, the radical Left has been intentional in making sure that our most influential cultural mechanisms—the educational system from kindergarten through doctoral programs, as well as overwhelming swaths of the media footprint—keep up the barrage of messaging about the United States being evil. Its history, its current state, its historical vision—all evil.

And the effort has been largely successful. For many citizens, the American values that have so clearly contrasted with socialist and communist ideals no longer facilitate national pride. The radical Left’s constant criticism of our nation is intricately connected to the dream of a communist utopia. When national pride is a thing of the past, “the warmth of collectivism” will be the thing of the present. This reality explains the growing acceptance of socialism and communism in the United States.

And this reality is related to an unfortunate trend in American Christianity: anti-American sentiment has found its way into large sections of the American Church. Many people who call themselves Christians have embraced the lie that patriotism and Christianity have no place together. Today, to be a Christian and vocally express appreciation for traditional American ideas is to be labeled as a “Christian nationalist,” a term that is increasingly embraced by the masses as a pejorative one. By joining the radical Left’s assault on American pride, much of the American Church is helping—sometimes knowingly, sometimes naively—to make the communist cause much more acceptable in the United States.

Well-meaning Christians who have embraced the trend of using the term “Christian nationalist” pejoratively must reject this impulse and understand that they have become actors in a movement that will only harm the Church and the nation, a nation that has flourished in large part because of its Judeo-Christian values. The idea that we cannot both love Christ and want the best for our nation is preposterous.

Moreover, the idea that the biblically orthodox Church in America is filled with pastors who are more passionate about the American flag and Constitutional rights than they are about the message of the cross is simply a myth. Perhaps there are a few, but I have sat under the instruction of many a patriotic pastor, and not one of them has ever given any indication that he loves country more than Christ or the Constitution more than Scripture. As with many caricatures of things having to do with the Christian Right, the accusation is overstated.

American Christians must push back against both the caricature and the general sentiment that they cannot love their country, lest they play a role in the main movement intended to facilitate a communist United States and thereby put in jeopardy the freedom to worship and practice religion—for Christianity is always a target of socialism and communism. Christianity is simply incompatible with both.


  1. Andrew Mark Miller, “‘Absolutely a Communist’: Mamdani Dodges Label, but His Record and Expert Say Otherwise,” Fox News, October 6, 2025, https://www.foxnews.com/politics/absolutely-communist-mamdani-dodges-label-his-record-expert-say-otherwise.
    ↩︎
  2. Ryan Bourne, “Mayor Mamdani’s ‘Collectivism” Is No Slip of the Tongue—It’s about Force, Coercion,” Fox News, January 6, 2026, https://www.cato.org/blog/mamdani-collectivism.
    ↩︎
  3. Victoria Balara, “Fox News Poll: Socialism Is Gaining Ground among Voters,” Fox News, March 5, 2026, https://www.foxnews.com/politics/fox-news-poll-socialism-gaining-ground-among-voters.
    ↩︎
  4. What We Saw: An Empire of Terror, on The Daily Wire, episode 4, March 26, 2024. ↩︎