How Socialism Will Financially Harm the Church
A Fox News poll from March 2026 indicated that “a record 38% [of Americans] think it would be a good thing for the United States to move away from capitalism and in the direction of socialism—up from 32% in 2022.” The Fox News article summarizing this data also noted that only 18% percent of Americans embraced socialism in 2010.1
For many big-hearted Christians, socialism sounds like an idea that comports with New Testament teaching. In fact, many Christians point to Acts 2:45 as a justification for socialism and, by implication, as a condemnation of capitalism. Acts 2:45 is the passage that addresses how the Christians of the early Church sold “their possessions and goods” and “gave to everyone as he had need.” Some pro-socialist Christians also point to Acts 4:32–35:
All the believers were one in heart and mind. No one claimed that any of his possessions was his own, but they shared everything they had. With great power the apostles continued to testify to the resurrection of the Lord Jesus, and much grace was upon them all. There were no needy persons among them. For from time to time those who owned lands or houses sold them, brought the money from the sales and put it at the apostles’ feet, and it was distributed to anyone as he had need.
On the surface, these two passages from Acts may indeed seem to suggest that the early Church was governed by a socialist ethic. However, as many have pointed out, Acts 4:32–35 makes clear that the early believers’ giving was not forced by a powerful ruling entity. They were not practicing socialism; they were being charitable—and charity, by its very nature, cannot be forced.
Moreover, the fact that some Christians sold land and were charitable with their earnings means that they owned land in the first place. They had wealth and disposable income, presumably because even the tax-happy Roman Empire wasn’t taking all they had. Those early Christians were able to help the needy financially and materially because they had disposable wealth with which to help. Socialism, on the other hand, prevents the masses from having such disposable income.
Many Christians have embraced a socialist ethic because they believe it comports well with the social-justice concerns that drive them. Those who have much should give to those who have little. I get it—and I agree that New Testament teaching calls believers to be charitable.
Unfortunately, for decades now, the educational system and the media have failed to teach that fairness means fairness for everyone, that those who have been blessed with much deserve fairness and justice too.
I remember a cultural moment almost 20 years ago when Joe “the Plumber” Wurzelbacher, a small-business owner who attended a presidential campaign rally, made a poignant point about the radical Left’s limited understanding of fairness. Wurzelbacher challenged a presidential candidate’s idea of raising his taxes simply because his success had landed him in a higher income bracket, noting that he had worked hard for fifteen years to build his business. Surely, implied the plumber, it was not fair to penalize him for his hard work. What if he dreamed of making a better life for his children and grandchildren because of his hard work? The moment underscored the fact that discussions of justice and fairness are often one sided.
Wurzelbacher’s encounter with the presidential candidate was implicitly anchored in one of the classic conservative arguments against high taxes: the people of the nation—not the government located in the insulated culture of Washington, D.C.—know better how to determine what is “just” and “fair” in their own cities, towns, and homes. Unfortunately, the limited-government argument that Wurzelbacher expressed so poignantly in 2008 has lost much of its effectiveness today.
And another traditional argument against the tax-and-spend mindset also seems to resonate with fewer Americans today than it once did. More traditional Americans understand that higher taxes lead to less innovation, for when the government takes more and more of people’s money, people become less motivated to do great things. And when people are less motivated to do great things, a nation suffers. Advances in technology and medicine decline, and the overall quality of life gets worse. But many people today gloss over this argument as well.
Misunderstanding about socialism and big government seems like such a mountainous problem that I become overwhelmed even thinking about it. However, I do believe that Christians who are warming to socialism, those who claim to love Jesus and His Church, can be challenged with an argument that they have perhaps never considered. I offer that argument here with the hope of generating some meaningful reflection among those believers who rightly care about social justice and understand that the Church indeed has been called to care for society’s less fortunate.
Many American Christians practice the biblical concept of tithing, which has traditionally been defined as the giving of ten percent of one’s income to the Church. Tithes generally go toward pastor salaries and other church expenses. Many Christians who tithe on a regular basis also give even more in the form of church offerings. Offerings go toward special projects that may or may not be directly related to the local church—all types of benevolence endeavors, for instance, including the fight against poverty at home and abroad.
Because the mainstream media seems to have it out for biblical Christianity and therefore paints the Church in the most negative light possible, most people do not realize how influential American Christians are with their financial offerings. For example, during the 2024–2025 fiscal year, Southern Baptists gave almost $280 million toward the denomination’s two most prominent missions offerings2 and another $186 million toward their Cooperative Program,3 which also funds missions work. When regular tithes and offerings are considered, Southern Baptists gave almost $9 billion last year.4 These numbers from just one denomination underscore the financial impact of the Church in America.
Socialism would negatively impact the good work that the American Church does through its generous givers. If America embraces socialism, people will have less and less disposable income. And with less disposable income, American Church tithes and offerings will decrease more and more—and perhaps even be rendered ineffective in terms of helping the less fortunate.
Some people may respond, “Wouldn’t it all balance out? Maybe the Church would lose some financial influence against poverty, but the government would gain revenue—in the form of higher taxes—to fight poverty, right?” This line of thinking ignores the reality of the American government’s love for bureaucracy. Far too many levels of bureaucracy already exist in America, and each level costs. That is, each level of bureaucracy requires employees, who belong to powerful unions, which demand employee salaries and benefits that are often disproportionate to the salaries and benefits of many non-government employees.
While there are already too many government agencies at the state and national levels, movement toward a socialist society would only create more of them. After all, government would surely create jobs and departments to oversee the supposed redistribution of wealth, and to pay for these jobs and departments, the government would inevitably take from the tax revenue that was intended to go “to the people.”
In short, bureaucracy is already too thick in America for socialism to be practical, and the poor are simply pawns in the socialism game. They would not really benefit after unions and government workers got their hands on their share of the tax treasure chest.
On the other hand, missionaries and other people in Christian ministry often make just enough money to survive. They are willing to lower their standard of living in order to help others; they take less so the people they help can have more. Furthermore, when non-profit organizations such as churches raise money to help people, a larger percentage of the money intended to help people actually gets to those for whom it is intended.
Would we be able to say the same about government-run programs made possible by hefty tax increases? No, the government benevolence system would result in a far lower percentage of money actually getting to those who need it. There are simply too many levels of bureaucracy.
The world has yet to see an economic system that is perfect, and capitalism certainly has some flaws. Yes, it allows the greedy to be greedy. But it also allows the generous to be generous, for under capitalist principles people are able to acquire disposable income and spend it the way they please. If we start punishing people just because they have more than others, then we can be sure that many generous rich people and well-off organizations will stop giving to causes for which the charity goes straight to the people who need it. Because the government will take more of their money, the wealthy will not be as generous, and a large percentage of the money that the government takes from them will go toward maintaining the bureaucracies associated with needs—not toward the needs themselves, and not toward churches, for people will have less to give.
- Victoria Balara, “Fox News Poll: Socialism Is Gaining Ground among Voters,” Fox News, March 5, 2026, https://www.foxnews.com/politics/fox-news-poll-socialism-gaining-ground-among-voters.
↩︎ - International Mission Board and North American Mission Board, “Southern Baptist Giving to Lottie Moon, Annie Armstrong Offerings Surpass $278 Million,” International Mission Board, October 13, 2025, https://www.imb.org/2025/10/13/southern-baptist-giving-to-lottie-moon-annie-armstrong-offerings-surpass-278-million/. ↩︎
- “CP Giving 2.19 Percent Below Budget for Fiscal Year,” Baptist Press, October 7, 2025, https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/cp-giving-2-19-percent-below-budget-for-fiscal-year/.
↩︎ - Aaron Earls, “Southern Baptists See Attendance and Baptism Gains Amid Membership Declines,” The Baptist Courier, May 5, 2026, https://baptistcourier.com/2026/05/southern-baptists-see-attendance-and-baptism-gains-amid-membership-declines/.
↩︎

